Schlosser, Julius Alwin von
Ritter Julius von Schlosser
Julius Alwin Schlosser-Magnino
Influential scholar and leader of the so-called (second) Vienna School of art history; successor to Max Dvořàk at the University of Vienna. Schlosser's parents were Wilhelm Valentin von Schlosser (1820-1870), a military administrator, and Sophie Maria Eiberger (1830-1916). His mother was of Italian extraction and instilled in Schlosser such a close association with Italy that friends referred to him a "Giulo" throughout his life. Schlosser was the "star pupil" of (first) Vienna-school scholar Franz Wickhoff at the University of Vienna, studying under him 1884-1887 and the classicist art historian Otto Benndorf. Schlosser wrote his dissertation on early medieval cloisters under Wickhoff, accepted in 1888. After graduation, Schlosser joined the Institut für Österreichische Geschichtsforschung (Institute of Austrian Historical Research) under the diplomatics historian Theodor von Sickel (1826-1908). Sickel instilled in Schlosser Sickel's strict appreciation for textual primary sources. After six months in research in Rome, he joined the staff of the Imperial collections (Kunsthistorische Hofmuseum, the modern Kunsthistorisches Museum) in Vienna in 1889, initally in the coins and medals division. Schlosser wrote his Habilitationsschrift in 1892. After a promotion to the and the arts and crafts collections, he was named director of the sculpture collection and (außerordentlicher) professor at Vienna in 1901. In 1903, he was offered a position at Prague, but declined to remain in Vienna. Schlosser's study of primary texts of art history led to an ever-greater fascination with Lorenzo Ghiberti. He published Ghiberti's memoirs in 1912. The following year he was knighted. In 1919 he became member of the Austrian academy of sciences. When the chair of the university's art history department, Max Dvořák, died unexpectedly in 1922, Schlosser was nominated as his replacement. Schlosser, initiallly urged Wilhelm Pinder to the position but ultimately accepted the Ordinarius appointment himself. The enmity between the more conventional Vienna scholars and their collegue, Josef Strzygowski, who had founded an art institute within the univeristy, grew to climax with Schlosser. In succeeding Dvořák, Schlosser now held the director chair of Strzygowski's Institut. The two split the Institute in an bitter bifurcation with Stryzgowski, claiming he held his chair longer, naming his instituion the first, Erstes Kunsthistorisches Institut or Wiener Institut. Schlosser maintained a separate art-historical institute to Strzygowski's, known as the second, Zweites Kunsthistorisches Institut. In 1924 he published the Die Kunstliteratur, and essay-style intellectual bibliography on writings on art. Schlosser maintained a close friendship with the Italian philosopher and art writer Benedetto Croce, whose works he translated into German. Croce's influence can be seen in Schlosser's "Stilgeschichte" und "Sprachgeschichte" in der bildenden Kunst of 1935, a Croce-like separation of art and non-art. His friendship with the literary historian Karl Vossler (1872-1949) strengthened his interest in textual history. He was named professor emeritus in 1936. His monograph on Ghiberti, which remained incomplete at his death, was published posthumously in 1941. Schlosser was succeeded by a former student, Hans Sedlmayr. Assertions that Schlosser was a member of the Nazi party appear untrue--perhaps based a photo of him wearing a swastika pin, required of all faculty in 1938 (Johns, 2012). His students included many of the important scholars of the late twentieth century as well as the art-historical diaspora from the Nazis. These included Ernst Kris, Otto Kurz, Ernst Gombrich, Otto Pächt, Sedlmayr, Fritz Saxl, Ludwig Goldschneider, Charles de Tolnay, Hans Robert Hahnloser and Gerhardt Ladner. A genuine polymath, he was also an excellent cellist and toured with a string quartet of which Hahnloser was the violist. In later years he personally adopted the family name "Schlosser-Magnino" in deference to his mother's family. He is buried in the Zentralfriedhof (cemetery) in Vienna. Schlosser is considered one of the giants of the discipline of art history in the twentieth century. Today, his best-known work is his survey of the entire corpus of western writing on art, from antiquity to modern times. Die Kunstliteratur includes guidebooks, technical treatises, works of criticism, and early historiography, providing an essential tool for appreciated the attitudes of artists and their public at all periods. Of particular interest to him were technical treatises and artists' writings. Die Kunstliteratur, ironically, was hardly exploited by art historians, who during his lifetime seldom consulted documents prefering stylistic analysis and connoisseurship which better served (as in the case of Bernard Berenson or Roberto Longhi) the art market. Gombrich cites Schlosser's interest in the fundamental question "What is Art?" as the reason why he at times selected comparatively minor art forms (for example, wax portraiture) to investigate. Methodologically, Schlosser embraced a Hegelian view of art, considering the individual artist to be the force of great art (as opposed to, for example, social conditions). This can most clearly be seen in his collected essays, Künstlerprobleme der Frührenaissance (1929). His writings, however, show a particular appreciation to the conditions under which art is produced, a similar approach to Aby Warburg, who was also of Schlosser's generation. Schlosser saw stylistic development ("Zeitstile") essentially as a fiction. Denying an evolution, his prefered scholarly text form was the monograph. The second half of Schlosser's life was devoted to the study of Lorenzo Ghiberti, whose influence Schlosser had come to appreciate through the study of primary texts. As an art historian, Schlosser eschewed the specialist's mantel. His articles ranged from ancient coinage "Kleinasiatische und thrakische Münzbilder der Kaiserzeit" (the Imperial coins of Asia Minor and Thrace) in 1891, to musical instruments, Kleiner Führer durch die Sammlung alter Musikinstrumente, (1922) to guides to the collections of the Imperial Museum. In terms of art historiography his books, Die Kunst- und Wunderkammern der Spätrenaissance, (1908) and Die Kunstliteratur are seminal. Dates of artwork were of less importance to him. Schlosser's Kunst des Mittelalters (1923), for example, uses art works without dates, an approach similar to Wilhelm Worringer. Such an emphasis put him at odds with other high-profile art scholars. These included museum scholars, in particular the powerful Berlin director Wilhelm von Bode; whereas Schlosser revered Ghiberti, Bode celebrated Donatello. Schlosser's emphasis on the autonomous character of the discipline of art history was the major intellectual friction with Strzygowski.
[nearly complete list of writings:] Johns, K. T. "Julius Alwin Ritter von Schlosser: ein bio-bibliographischer Beitrag." Kritische Berichte 16/4 (1989): 47-64; Die abendländisches Klosteranlage des früheren Mittelalters. Vienna, 1888, published, Vienna: Gerold, 1889; "Kleinasiatische und thrakische Münzbilder der Kaiserzeit." Numismatische Zeitschrift 23 (1891): 1-28; "Schriftquellen zur karolingischen Kunst." Quellenschriften zur Kunstgeschichte, Neue Folge IV. Vienna: C. Graeser, 1892; Die Kunst- und Wunderkammern der Spätrenaissance: ein Beitrag zur Geschichte des Sammelwesens. Leipzig: Klinkhardt & Biermann, 1908; "Lorenzo Ghibertis Denkwürdigkeiten. Prologomena zu einer künftigen Ausgabe." Jahrbuch der K. K. Zentralkommission 4 (1910): 105ff.; Lorenzo Ghibertis Denkwürdigkeiten (I Commentarii). Zum ersten Maler nach der Handschrift der Biblioteca Nazionale vollständig herausgeben und erläutert. 2 vols. Berlin: Julius Bard, 1912; Kleiner Führer durch die Sammlung alter Musikinstrumente. Vienna: A. Schroll, 1922; Die Kunst des Mittelalters. Berlin-Potsdam: Athenaion, 1923; Die Kunstliteratur: ein Handbuch zur Quellenkunde der neueren Kunstgeschichte. Vienna: Anton Schroll, 1924, Italian, La letteratura artistica; manuale delle fonti della storia dell'arte moderna. Florence Nuova Italia, 1935. 3rd ed., 1964; supplement, appendix by Otto Kurz, 1937, 2nd ed., 1956; Künstlerprobleme der Frührenaissance. 3 vols. Vienna/Leipzig: Hölder-Pichler-Tempsky, 1929-1934; Die Wiener Schule der Kunstgeschichte. Innsbruck: Wagner, 1934, English, "The Vienna School of Art History." trans. Karl T. Johns. Journal of Art Historiography 1 (December 2009): 1-50; "Stilgeschichte" und "Sprachgeschichte" in der bildenden Kunst. Munich: Verlag der Bayerischen Akademie der Wissenschaften, 1935; "über Stilgeschichte- und Sprachgeschichte der bildenden Kunst: ein Rückblick." Sitzungberichte der bayrischen Akademie der Wissenschaft, Philosophisch-Historisch Abteilung 1, pp. 3-39, 1939; Leben und Meinungen des florentinischen Bildners Lorenzo Ghiberti. Basle: Holbein-Verlag, 1941.
"Julius von Schlosser." in, Jahn, Johannes, ed. Die Kunstwissenschaft der Gegenwart in Selbstdarstellung. 2 vols. Leipzig: F. Meiner, 1924, pp. 95-134; "Festschrift für Julius Schlosser zum 60. Geburtstag." Jahrbuch der kunsthistorischen Sammlungen in Wien Neue Folge, 1 (1927); Julius Schlosser: Festschrift zu seinem 60sten Geburtstag. Edited by Arpad Weixlgärtner and Leo Planiscig. Vienna: Amalthea, 1927; Kurz, Otto. "Julius von Schlosser: Personlita-Metodo-Lavoro." Critica d'arte 11/12 (1955): 402-419 [confirmation of death date]; Dvorák, Max. Idealism and Naturalism in Gothic Art. Preface by Karl Maria Swoboda. Notre Dame, IN: University of Notre Dame Press, 1967, p. 222; Kleinbauer, W. Eugene. Modern Perspectives in Western Art History: An Anthology of 20th-Century Writings on the Visual Arts. New York: Holt, Rinehart and Winston, 1971, pp. 3, 4, 89 cited; Kleinbauer, W. Eugene. Research Guide to the History of Western Art. Chicago: American Library Association, 1982, p. 122 mentioned; Podro, Michael. "Against Formalism: Schlosser on Stilgeschichte." Akten des XXV. internationalen Kongresses für Kunstgeschichte (Vienna, 1983): vol. i, pp. 37-43; Wölfflin, Heinrich. Heinrich Wölfflin, 1864-1945: Autobiographie, Tagebücher und Briefe. Joseph Ganter, ed. 2nd ed. Basel: Schwabe & Co., 1984, p. 493; Bazin, Germain. Histoire de l'histoire de l'art; de Vasari à nos jours. Paris: Albin Michel, 1986, p. 164; German Essays on Art History. Gert Schiff, ed. New York: Continuum, 1988, pp. liii-lvi, 281; Johnson, W. McAllister. Art History: Its Use and Abuse. Toronto: University of Toronto Press, 1988, p. 21; Gombrich, Ernst H. "Einige Erinnerungen an Julius von Schlosser als Lehrer." Kritische Berichte 16/4 (1989): 5-9; Haja, M. "Schlosser Julius Alwin von." Österreichisches Biographisches Lexikon 1815-1950 10 (1994): 218-219; Metzler Kunsthistoriker Lexikon: zweihundert Porträts deutschsprachiger Autoren aus vier Jahrhunderten. Stuttgart: Metzler, 1999, pp. 350-53; Rosenauer, Arthur. "Schlosser, Julius." Dictionary of Art; Aurenhammer, Hans H. "Schlosser, Julius Ritter von." Neue Deutsche Biographie 23 (2007): 105-107; Aurenhammer, Hans. Kunstgeschichte an der Universität Wien; Karl T. Johns, personal correspondence, December, 2012: Gombrich, Ernst. "Julius von Schlosser." The Burlington Magazine 74 no. 431 (February 1939): 98-99; Sedlmayr, Hans. "Julius Ritter von Schlosser." Mitteilungen des Instituts für Österreichische Geschichtsforschung 52 (1938): 513-519; Hahnloser, Hans R. "Zum Gedächtnis von Julius von Schlosser." Belvedere 13 (1938-43): 137-141.